Why is Brampton East MP Raj Grewal disgracing himself even more? And what about MP Tony Clement?

Dear Brampton East You Deserve To Know. I’ve asked for this opportunity to speak directly to my fellow Canadians about my mental health issue with gambling. I know my silence this past week has raised questions and speculation – and for that, I truly apologize. This has been an agonizing time for me as I’ve wrestled with the issue of how my illness impacts my role as an MP and my family. I now want to speak freely and share my story, because Canadians deserve to know what happened. I have gambled recreationally since university and never thought I would suffer from mental health and addiction issues. But it became a significant personal problem that I now recognize and take responsibility for. During my time in Ottawa as an MP, I stayed at the Hilton Hotel in Gatineau Quebec, which coincidentally was interconnected to the Casino du Lac Leamy. In early 2016, I first started to visit the Casino recreationally to play blackjack. This quickly escalated into a significant problem as I started to play high stakes, high limit blackjack. On an average sitting, I would spend between 15 to 30 minutes at a table, and I either won a lot of money, which made me continue to chase wins, or I lost a significant amount of money, which threw me into complete despair.Over a 3 year period, I accumulated personal debt in the millions of dollars. Like many addicts and people suffering from mental health issues, I started to personally borrow money solely from friends and family to continue to gamble. I want to make it clear, that every single personal loan made to me was by cheque. Everybody has been paid back, and every loan and repayment is transparent and traceable. This has nothing to do at all with anything sinister except to feed my own addiction. I apologize to my family for both having to financially bail me out and to carry this burden with me. I know I have shocked many and left everyone wondering how someone with education and privilege could do something so senseless. The truth is, that compulsive gambling is a mental health disorder that I suffer from. One that was fueled by my misguided belief that one more win could fix the problem. I cannot put into words the shame and embarrassment that comes with this addiction, particularly for my family and friends. It is not easy to admit that you have a problem, especially when you are in the public realm. That is why I did not stop. That is why I hid this from absolutely everyone. And that is why I suffered in silence. On November 5, I first revealed this problem to my family. It is with their love and support that I had the courage to seek treatment and speak to the Prime Minister’s Office on November 19, 2018, which is the first time I notified PMO about my mental health and gambling addiction issues. My sins are not ones based in corruption and dishonesty; they are born out of human frailty. I want to apologize to my family, friends, and supporters – I am sorry to have disappointed you. You have all poured so much time, energy and love into me and that I will never forget. To my constituents and colleagues – you put your faith in me to serve and I let you down. To the Prime Minister, I sincerely apologize for becoming a distraction from the important work you are doing for Canadians. As commonly happens when a news story like this one breaks, many want to know the details and may rely upon isolated pieces of information and half truths in an attempt to fit them into the narrative. In my own situation, this happened in several instances, particularly in relation to work as an MP on the house Finance Committee and on the subject of my and my wife’s personal purchases. I would like to fully clear these up now with specific facts. With respect to my role as a member of the Standing Committee on Finance, I participated in a review of the Proceeds of Crime and Terrorist Financing Act where MPs ask particular agencies and institutions pertinent questions. As part of this review, my committee colleagues and I asked questions of a similar nature on money laundering. My questions on February 8th and June 20th were based in part on a brief prepared by the Library of Parliament, which included recommended questions, and additional suggestions by my staff. To infer that my motivations were unethical or that I was using a chance opportunity to figure out if FINTRAC was aware of my gambling is to stretch reality and to take the situation completely out of context. Additionally, after having served on the finance committee for three years, I wanted to try something new to diversify my experience. For this reason, when a vacancy occurred on the Standing Committee on Health, I welcomed the new opportunity and was appointed on September 19, 2018. There is also incorrect information that has been published about me and my wife’s assets and liabilities that give rise to unfair inferences. As I mentioned before, my wife had no idea about my personal gambling problem until 3 weeks ago. We have been married for only 4 months now and have always maintained separate finances. We do not even have a joint bank account. In January 2018, my wife and I jointly purchased one condo in Toronto for $1.44 million where we currently have a mortgage for $1 million. Like many young Canadians, we worked hard, saved, received help from our parents and invested in real estate as part of our financial plan. The media has implied that the mortgage is in excess of its purchase price, which is not true and not possible under Canada’s banking regime. Additionally, my wife independently purchased a condo four years ago in 2014 for $324,000 with a mortgage for $278,000. I have no ownership in this property and reports of a third condo are false. My wife is a respected and hardworking lawyer. She is not a public figure and it is wrong for her to be implicated by the media, and have her name dragged into this when she had no idea about my personal finances and problems. Again I apologize to her and her family for the grief I caused them. I also have a personal line of credits with three financial institutions, which were disclosed to the ethics commissioner and all are related to my student debts.Additionally, I want to clarify that I only have one personal vehicle. I co-signed one lease to help a friend who needed a car loan, which was the 2018 Dodge Ram. I am not a debtor on any other personal vehicles.There have also been reports about my involvement with the Goreway Bridge project. Since the 2015 campaign, I have been advocating for the Goreway bridge to be completed, because it is an important issue for the people of Brampton East. Throughout my term as an MP, I have routinely requested updates on the status of the project from the Mayor’s office. The sole purpose of my inquiries was to ensure that I could provide an update to my constituents on the status of the project. As part of the routine update request, myself and other recipients received an email containing an unsolicited confidential report from the Mayor of Brampton’s Chief of Staff on November 21, 2017. I did nothing further with this report and to suggest that I leaked confidential information is categorically false. With respect to my other employment relationships, I want to reiterate that they were both disclosed to and approved by the ethics commissioner. Since January 2018, I ended my relationship with one employer and continued to work in a limited capacity with another for the purposes of maintaining my legal skill set. I have worked with the ethics commissioner regarding my employment and will continue to cooperate with his office. What does this all mean for the people of Brampton East? On Wednesday, November 21, after a brief conversation with the Chief Government Whip, I was told that I probably could not remain in caucus and should resign my seat. I asked the government whip to allow me to make my own statement and to tell my family in person. I immediately flew back to Brampton to share the heartbreaking news with my family.In a highly emotional state, completely exhausted and facing an extreme time constraint, I made an ill advised statement on Facebook that I would be resigning my seat. I can see how some might think that it is right for me to resign. For me, this is a very difficult decision to make. In 2015, I made a commitment to the people of Brampton East – to work hard, to be accessible and to represent them in Ottawa – this job remains unfinished. Brampton East and I share a very special bond. Its where I grew up, its where I went to school and its where I will continue to live and serve – no matter whether it's in the public or private realm. After weeks of spending time with my family, receiving treatment, and countless messages of support, in particular from individuals suffering from mental health issues and my constituents, I’ve decided that I will be leaving the Liberal Caucus and taking a leave of absence to focus on my mental health and recovery. I do not take this decision lightly, as it is easier for my family and me to just fade away and avoid the daily media scrutiny this will bring. But I’m prepared to bear up to the embarrassment and recriminations that are sure to come my way, and legitimately so. I will be making a final decision about my political future before Parliament resumes in the new year. During this time, I ask the people of Brampton East for their patience, guidance, and prayers to ensure that the right decision is made. Thank you.Raj

Posted by Raj Grewal on Friday, November 30, 2018

 

CHIEF Government Whip Mark Holland, MP for Ajax, in a tweet on Saturday, announced: “I confirmed, in writing, earlier this morning to the Speaker of the House of Commons that Raj Grewal, MP for Brampton East, is not a member of the Liberal Caucus.”

It is terribly deplorable that some South Asian MPs over the past two decades have brought much shame on such a vibrant and progressive community such as ours, thus giving racists an excuse to heap their scorn on us.

Grewal’s behaviour will only garner contempt for him rather than the sympathy people were willing to show at first.

He is now shamelessly clinging on to his seat after giving the impression that he had a problem with gambling and was ready to take treatment for it and thus redeem himself. He was to quit his position as MP and leave the Liberal caucus.

But all the sympathetic support that he was getting will now vanish.

He was first exposed by the Conservative Party last week on Wednesday when MP Peter Kent announced: “Yesterday, we learned that Mr. Grewal has, in fact, not resigned as Member of Parliament, despite statements from the PMO and Government House Leader indicating he had.”

He added: “Andrew Scheer’s Conservatives demand the Prime Minister remove Mr. Grewal from the Liberal caucus, and join us in asking for his immediate and official resignation from the House of Commons.”

Kent also bluntly noted: “Today, Canadians learned from media reports that Raj Grewal abused his position on the powerful House of Commons Finance committee by asking self-serving questions about money laundering to senior officials in the RCMP and other law-enforcement agencies. These questions appear to be directly related to his gambling activities, for which he is currently under RCMP investigation. This is in addition to the Ethics Commissioner’s investigation launched earlier this year into his decision to bring his non-Parliamentary employer on Justin Trudeau’s trip to India.”

On Friday, Grewal told the Globe and Mail that “every loan and repayment is transparent and retraceable. … My sins are not ones based in corruption and dishonesty. They are borne out of human frailty.”

And he called announcing his resignation on his Facebook “ill-advised,” adding that he would wait until January to make a permanent decision, and that he is seeking help for his gambling problem, the Globe and Mail reported.

Quite obviously, expecting the opposition parties to go ballistic on this issue, Justin Trudeau finally decided to act to end this embarrassing situation by ordering the chief government whip to kick Grewal out of caucus.

Such shameless, self-serving behaviour by Grewal deserves condemnation.

 

Tony Clement

MEANWHILE, Conservative MPs are keeping quiet about why their former colleague Tony Clement, M.P. for Parry Sound-Muskoka, also refuses to resign as MP after his disgusting sexual behaviour was exposed.

Clement had resigned as the party’s justice critic when a sextortion scandal involving him came to light. He revealed: “Over the last three weeks, I have shared sexually explicit images and a video of myself to someone who I believed was a consenting female recipient. The recipient was, in fact, an individual or party who targeted me for the purpose of financial extortion. The RCMP are currently investigating the matter to determine the identity of the party responsible for the extortion attempt.”

However, the former federal minister had to be kicked out of the Conservative Party when party leader Andrew Scheer found that there was more than one allegation of sexual impropriety against him.

But Clement refused to quit as MP, stating: “I love my job and I love my family. I am committed to getting the professional help I need to continue serving my family, my community and my country in whatever ways I can. I wish to sincerely thank the many members of our community who have reached out to convey their thoughts and prayers to me. I can assure the residents of Parry Sound – Muskoka that my offices remain open and at your service, and that I will continue to uphold the responsibilities of being your Member of Parliament.”

Shamelessness seems to be the way to go for our politicians, eh!

As the Toronto Star put it: “The career explosions of Clement and Grewal this fall are a fascinating look into the lives and temptations of ordinary MPs. A few more and we could have a reality-TV series on Netflix.”

 

 

ALSO READ:

 

Liberal MP Raj Grewal resigned over gambling addiction and significant debts: PMO (update)

Former Liberal MP Raj Grewal’s gambling activity has been under RCMP investigation for months, reports Globe and Mail

Scheer kicks out Clement from caucus over sexual impropriety allegations; scandal a serious blow to Conservatives (UPDATE)